CBC’s “The Fifth Estate” tackles doctor/patient boundaries

Yesterday, the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation finally telecast an investigative report on their esteemed series “The Fifth Estate” about doctors who cross the line with their patients.

Titled “Doctors Without Boundaries,” its premise is: When doctors are accused of crossing ethical or legal boundaries with their female patients, why does it take so long for authorities to protect the public – if they act at all? An investigation by Bob McKeown.

The video is available on this link: http://www.cbc.ca/player/play/2682489042/

If due to some reason, CBC shows cannot be live-streamed in your country, you can watch the report on youtube here:

About time the CBC – which had a few internal scandals of various kinds over the years, most famously its shocking Jian Ghomeshi scandal – aired a report like this.

For what its worth, this blog had once questioned why the Fifth Estate hadn’t already done so – i.e. an investigative report on doctors who cross ethical and legal boundaries such as Levin.

Good work, CBC. Greatly appreciated. Better late than never.

One of the doctors profiled in the documentary is sleazy psychiatrist Stanley Debrowolski. Details from his case can also be read here: http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2015/11/30/psychiatrists-decades-of-sex-transgressions-over.html

Another “dirty doc” is psychiatrist Ravi Shenava. http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2016/01/21/us-psychiatrist-faces-criminal-sex-assault-charges-in-canada-cbc-reports.html

Also featured is Dr. Patrick Nesbitt, who was unethical and abusive toward both his female patients and his wife. http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/doctor-faces-criminal-charges-patrick-nesbitt-1.3413645

A must-see documentary. Viewer discretion advised.

Last week, another strange case of a prominent doctor crossing lines was reported in several newspapers in New York. The case of David Newman MD, a highly respected doctor who was accused of ejaculating into the mouth of his semi-conscious female patient. Here are two reports from the New York Times:

“E.R. Doctor at Mt. Sinai Hospital Charged With Sexual Abuse of 2 Patients” http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/20/nyregion/er-doctor-at-mt-sinai-hospital-charged-with-sexual-abuse-of-2-patients.html

“A prominent emergency room doctor at Mount Sinai Hospital in Manhattan was arrested on Tuesday and accused of drugging, groping and masturbating on a female patient and groping another in separate episodes several months apart, the authorities said. The charges against the doctor, David H. Newman, 45, a proponent of reforms in emergency care who has written widely about improving doctor-patient relationships, describe him targeting young women for abuse when they sought medical treatment.”

And, this:

“Colleagues Express Disbelief Over Arrest of Doctor With Picture-Perfect Life” http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/21/nyregion/colleagues-express-disbelief-over-arrest-of-doctor-with-picture-perfect-life.html

“Dr. David H. Newman seemed to have it all: an impressive post in emergency medicine at Mount Sinai Hospital, a prominent and growing public presence as an expert in health care reform, a wife who is a doctor, two young sons, and a gracious home in the New Jersey suburbs. So when he was arrested on Tuesday and charged with sexually abusing two patients under his care in the emergency room, the reaction from his wide circle of colleagues was disbelief.”



Remember that…

…Not giving a F%*# and moving on with your life – after exposing the hypocritical monsters for who they are – is the best revenge against those who abuse or play with your life.

Stay Strong! Especially those who’ve sent me heart-rending e-mails outlining abuses they faced from systems and the Shock Doc and/or other persons-in-power.

New Year Greetings to my readers. More blog posts coming soon.

In the meantime – perhaps this applies to certain unprofessional practitioners ;) ? (see our blogroll links.)





Dr. Shock: a detailed look

Recently, the esteemed Canadian magazine “The Walrus” featured an excellent and well-constructed piece on Levin written by Richard Poplak titled “Dr. Shock: how an apartheid-era psychiatrist went from torturing gay soldiers in South Africa to sexually abusing patients in Alberta.”

Here is the link: https://thewalrus.ca/doctor-shock/

INSPECTED from above, there is nothing—just the converging serpents of the Limpopo and Shashe Rivers, and a plateau surrounded by endless tracts of veld. In 1970, a military camp was built here, overseen by a psychiatrist who believed firmly in the curative power of pain. In apartheid’s darkest corners, he was known as die Kolonel, his camp was christened Greefswald, and no two terms inspired more dread in the members of the South African Defence Force, themselves experts in the creation and dissemination of terror….(continue reading on https://thewalrus.ca/doctor-shock/)

Aubrey Levin’s wife Erica Levin gets conditional sentence for bribery attempt of juror

Erica Levin will receive an 18-month conditional sentence with house arrest and 180 hours of community service for her failed attempt at bribing a juror at her infamous husband’s trial.

All the details are in the following links:

The Calgary Herald with full details: http://calgaryherald.com/news/crime/erica-levin-faces-jail-for-attempting-to-bribe-juror-at-husbands-sex-trial

…..Saying she had been suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder and depression at the time of the incident, Court of Queen’s Bench Justice Karen Horner handed the 72-year-old woman an 18-month conditional sentence with house arrest and 180 hours of community service.

Horner called Ms. Levin’s crime “selfish” and “reckless.”

“The emotional distress the juror was put through was no fault of her own,” said Horner. “She said after speaking to Ms. Levin she was in such shock she had to get away from the court house and go home. She reported it to the judge after the weekend.

“I do not accept that trying to bribe a juror is the same as trying to bribe a witness. A juror is one of 12 judges. To single out a juror is the same as trying to bribe a judge.”….(contd. in the above link)

From Global News Canada (contains video): http://globalnews.ca/news/2001222/woman-gets-18-month-conditional-sentence-after-bribing-juror-in-husbands-trial/

From the French CBC Radio-Canada: http://ici.radio-canada.ca/regions/alberta/2015/05/16/001-peine-sursis-erica-levin.shtml

From the English CBC: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/erica-levin-not-going-to-prison-for-trying-to-bribe-juror-at-husband-s-sex-assault-trial-1.3076386

From the Calgary Sun: http://www.calgarysun.com/2015/05/15/wife-of-disgraced-calgary-doctor-escapes-jail-time-after-attempt-to-bribe-juror-during-husbands-sexual-assault-trial

President Obama Calls for End to ‘Conversion’ Therapies for Gay and Transgender Youth

If there was any doubt that the “conversion” process Aubrey Levin was imparting in South Africa was evil, or that such practices are criminal – please note that this is a topic taken seriously even by the highest govt. authorities. Justice Canada, are you listening? Once again, how could you let a known criminal like “Dr.” Levin enter Canada and give him a medical license to practice and a professorship?

President Obama Calls for End to ‘Conversion’ Therapies for Gay and Transgender Youth – The New York Times, April 8, 2015

The following is the text from the original article by Michael D. Shear published in The New York Times and can be accessed by clicking on this link: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/09/us/politics/obama-to-call-for-end-to-conversion-therapies-for-gay-and-transgender-youth.html?_r=0


WASHINGTON — A 17-year-old transgender youth, Leelah Alcorn, stunned her friends and a vast Internet audience in December when she threw herself in front of a tractor-trailer after writing in an online suicide note that religious therapists had tried to convert her back to being a boy.

In response, President Obama is calling for an end to such therapies aimed at “repairing” gay, lesbian and transgender youth. His decision on the issue is the latest example of his continuing embrace of gay rights.

In a statement that was posted on Wednesday evening alongside a WhiteHouse.gov petition begun in honor of Ms. Alcorn, Mr. Obama condemned the practice, sometimes called “conversion” or “reparative” therapy, which is supported by some socially conservative organizations and religious doctors.

The petition has received more than 120,000 signatures in three months.

In an interview on Wednesday, Ms. Jarrett said Mr. Obama had been moved by the story of Ms. Alcorn’s suicide. But she said the problem went far beyond Ms. Alcorn.

“It was tragic, but I will tell you, unfortunately, she has a lot of company,” Ms. Jarrett said. “It’s not the story of one young person. It is the story of countless young people who have been subjected to this.”

Mr. Obama will not explicitly call for a federal law banning therapists from using such therapies on their patients, but he is open to conversations with lawmakers in both parties, White House officials said on Wednesday. Instead, he will throw his support behind the efforts to ban the practice at the state level.

Mr. Obama began his national political career opposed to gay marriage and accepting of limits on gays’ serving in the military. But he now supports same-sex marriage and has sought greater equality of treatment for gay men and lesbians in the government and the private work force. In his first term, he pushed the Pentagon to end the “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy that had kept gay service members from serving openly.

On Wednesday, Mr. Obama’s top aides also heralded new protections for gay federal workers that went into effect this week. Last summer, Mr. Obama issued executive orders to ban discrimination on the basis of gender identity and sexual orientation by federal contractors.

Officials also announced the creation of an “all-gender restroom” in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building, where many of the White House staff members work, to provide an additional option for transgender individuals who are not comfortable using either the men’s or women’s restrooms.

Therapists who advocate the use of the gender identity therapies promote them as a way of helping gay people change their sexual orientation. Those therapists reject claims that sexual orientation or identity is unchangeable and argue that gay or transgender identities should be reversed so that people can embrace their “authentic” heterosexual selves.

“So-called ‘conversion therapy’ is a range of dangerous and discredited practices that falsely claim to change a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity or expression,” the group said in a statement.

In Ms. Jarrett’s letter, which was posted on WhiteHouse.gov, the White House says that stopping the gender identity therapies will help make the United States a more welcoming place for gay people.

“Tonight, somewhere in America, a young person, let’s say a young man, will struggle to fall to sleep, wrestling alone with a secret he’s held as long as he can remember,” the statement says. “Soon, perhaps, he will decide it’s time to let that secret out. What happens next depends on him, his family, as well as his friends and his teachers and his community. But it also depends on us — on the kind of society we engender, the kind of future we build.”

David Pickup, a licensed family therapist in California and Texas, said in an interview on Wednesday that the president and gay rights advocates were purposely misconstruing the work that he and others do. He said that minors should never be forced into therapy, but he insisted that being gay was often brought about by serious emotional problems or sexual abuse.

“We believe that change is still possible. People go to therapy because they can change, because it really does work,” Mr. Pickup said. “We help people grow into their authentic selves.”

Mr. Pickup said he and others were actively lobbying against the proposed state bans, and he urged Mr. Obama to “wake up and understand the rights of people who he doesn’t know anything about and need his help and need his compassion.”


Latest update on Erica Levin’s bribery case and latest round of excuses

From the Calgary Sun. Link to the main article here: http://www.calgarysun.com/2015/03/27/calgary-courtroom-told-post-traumatic-stress-disorder-behind-attempt-by-erica-levin-to-bribe-juror

Calgary courtroom told post-traumatic stress disorder behind attempt by Erica Levin to bribe juror

– Kevin Martin kevin.martin@sunmedia.ca


The wife of disgraced court doctor Aubrey Levin was suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder when she attempted to bribe a juror in his trial, court heard Thursday.

Psychiatrist Dr. Mansfield Mela testified he determined the Calgary woman was also suffering from major depression, in part for her husband’s prosecution for sexually assaulting male patients.

Mela said Levin, 71, was on antidepressants at the time of her husband’s prosecution, but the medication wasn’t working properly when she offered cash to a juror.

“She needed an adjustment after the offence, which seemed to bring her back to a stable mental state,” Mela told defence counsel Michael Bates.

Levin was found guilty last October of attempted obstruction for trying to bribe a juror in her husband’s trial.

The juror testified she was approached by the woman on a CTrain platform across from the Calgary Courts Centre.

She told court Levin said “here, a thousand dollars, please don’t find my husband guilty,” as she held out a thick white envelope.”

The juror was ultimately dismissed from the case after disclosing the incident to Justice Donna Shelley, while her colleagues went on to find Aubrey Levin guilty of molesting three male patients.

He is currently serving a five-year prison term on three charges he sexually assaulted male patients at his office at the Peter Lougheed Centre.

One of those patients secretly videotaped the abuse using a spy camera watch, leading to his successful prosecution.

A date to continue Erica Levin’s sentencing hearing will be set May 1.

Aubrey Levin’s bid to appeal sex assault convictions denied by Supreme Court

Link below from the CBC which in the last week has been riddled with its own top-star’s scandal, as more and more women are coming out with stories of violent sexualized encounters with the CBC’s former golden boy Jian Ghomeshi. (And yes, it did bring back memories for me of the emails I received last year from the brave women who had written about the public persona vs private conduct of a certain Toronto psychiatrist (not Levin) who also had a gig with the CBC, although for the benefit of fact, I will say that those revelations, though dark, definitely did not involve hitting, slapping, biting or anything that physically hurtful and violent. This is not to minimize the pain suffered or its nature.)

In any case, as in the case of Levin or others in positions of power within their respective fields – it goes to show that smiling, charming, seemingly kind and “intellectual” public personas have little to do with the stark contrasts people may exhibit or possess behind closed doors. The hypocrisy of narcissists.


The Supreme Court of Canada has shut the door on a psychiatrist’s request to appeal three convictions for sexually assaulting his court-appointed patients.

Dr. Aubrey Levin of Calgary was found guilty by a jury in January 2013 and was sentenced to five years in prison.

He had asked the Supreme Court to hear an appeal of his convictions, but that request has been denied.

As always, the top court did not give reasons for its decision.

Allegations against Levin came to light in 2010 after (read more)